T 1439/10 13-03-2013

Reasons for the Decision

1. The appeal is admissible.

2. Claim 18 according to the main request - Amendments, Article 123(2) EPC

2.1 Claim 18 according to the main request discloses over claim 20 as granted the additional features that

"the packaging material holder (110) includes a clamp for grasping, holding, and releasing packaging material (116) and a mechanical movement for actuating the clamp, the clamp including jaws (112, 114) mounted on a rail mounted on the turntable (122) to allow the jaws (112, 114) to translate relative to the turntable (122)".

2.2 The appellant referred to the single specific apparatus embodiment depicted in the figures 1A to 4B and the corresponding description parts of the application as filed, page 6, lines 11 to 13, 17 to 19 and 22 to 23, as forming the basis for introducing the above-mentioned additional features into claim 18.

2.3 The Board notes that the apparatus according to the single specific embodiment disclosed in the application as filed is depicted in the figures 1A to 4B and described on page 6, line 3 to page 12, line 10 of the application as filed. Said apparatus comprises inter alia a packaging material holder 110 including jaws 112, 114 mounted on a rail mounted on the turntable 122, a mechanical movement mounted on the turntable and including a floating cam in form of a ramp 150 having an upper surface 152 and a lower surface 154, a cam follower 158 which allows the jaws to travel on said surfaces 152, 154, a cog element 132 consisting of an engaging element 134, a chain element 136 and a release element 138. The apparatus discloses further an actuator for the mechanical movement, said actuator being positioned apart from the turntable 122 and including a pin 130. A controller is further disclosed in said apparatus for engaging the pin 30 with the engaging element 134. This specific feature's combination allows the packaging material holder 110 to be isolated from any electrical or fluid source of power by the turntable, i.e. it allows the turntable to not carry electrical or fluid power sources with it during rotation and to act as a barrier between the packaging material holder and any electrical or fluid source of power, see page 9, lines 5 to 15 of the application as filed.

2.4 According to the established case law of the Boards of Appeal, if a claim is restricted to a preferred embodiment, it is normally not admissible under Article 123(2) EPC to extract isolated features from a set of features which have originally been disclosed in combination for that embodiment. Such kind of amendment would only be justified in the absence of any clearly recognisable functional or structural relationship among said features (see e.g. T 1067/97, point 2.1.3).

2.5 In the present case, claim 18 according to the main request although it defines some additional specific structural features of the packaging material holder it leaves out at the same time further structural features of said packaging material holder, for example the cog element, as well as features like the controller or the pin-actuator positioned apart from the turntable, said features being indispensable for having the packaging material holder from the claimed apparatus isolated from any electrical or fluid power source by the rotatable turntable.

2.6 The skilled reader would consider the presence of

a) an actuator for the mechanical movement positioned apart from the turntable and including a pin;

b) a cog element consisting of an engaging element, a chain element and a release element; and

c) a controller actuating the pin for engaging the engaging element,

as indispensable for providing a functioning apparatus according to the present invention having a packaging material holder isolated from any electrical or fluid power source by the rotatable turntable.

2.7 Therefore, since claim 18 results from the extraction of isolated features from the specific feature's combination disclosed as essential in the single apparatus embodiment of the application as filed, and since the appellant did not refer to other parts of the application as filed that could support the proposed amendment, nor have such parts been identified by the Board, claim 18 as amended in accordance with the main request does not meet the requirements of Article 123(2) EPC.

3. Claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 1 - Amendments, Article 123(2) EPC

3.1 Claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 1 discloses over claim 18 according to the main request the additional features that

"the mechanical movement being mounted on the turntable and including a floating cam in the form of a ramp (150) having an upper surface (152) and a lower surface (154), the mechanical movement further including a cam follower (158) which allows the jaws (112, 114) to travel on the surfaces (152, 154)".

3.2 The appellant referred to the single specific apparatus embodiment depicted in the figures 1A to 4B and the corresponding description parts of the application as filed, page 6, line 28 to page 7, line 2 and page 7, lines 11 to 13, as forming the basis for introducing the above-mentioned additional features into claim 18.

3.3 The same argumentation concerning the single specific apparatus embodiment of the application as filed as presented under point 2 above in connection with claim 18 according to the main request applies mutatis mutandis also for claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 1.

3.4 As pointed out under point 2.6 above the skilled reader would consider the presence of

a) an actuator for the mechanical movement positioned apart from the turntable and including a pin;

b) a cog element consisting of an engaging element, a chain element and a release element; and

c) a controller actuating the pin for engaging the engaging element

as indispensable for providing a functioning apparatus according to the present invention having a packaging material holder isolated from any electrical or fluid power source by the rotatable turntable.

3.5 The above-mentioned features are not present in claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 1 and thus claim 18 of said request results from the extraction of isolated features from the specific feature's combination disclosed as essential in the single apparatus embodiment of the application as filed.

3.6 Since the appellant did not refer to other parts of the application as filed that could support the proposed amendment, nor have such parts been identified by the Board, claim 18 as amended in accordance with the auxiliary request 1 does not meet the requirements of Article 123(2) EPC.

4. Claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 2 - Amendments, Article 123(2) EPC

4.1 Claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 2 discloses over claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 1 the additional features that

"movement of the cam follower (158) up onto the upper surface (152) of the ramp (150) automatically causes the jaws (112, 114) to open, wherein the jaws (112, 114) remain open as long as the cam follower (158) is moving along the upper surface (152) of the ramp (150), and wherein the cam follower (158) rolling off the end of the ramp (150) automatically causes the jaws (112, 114) to close".

4.2 The appellant referred to the single specific apparatus embodiment depicted in the figures 1A to 4B and the corresponding description parts of the application as filed, page 7, lines 17 to 23, as forming the basis for introducing the above-mentioned additional features into claim 18.

4.3 The same argumentation concerning the single specific apparatus embodiment of the application as filed as presented under points 2 and 3 above in connection with claim 18 according to the main request and according to the auxiliary request 1 applies mutatis mutandis also for claim 18 of the auxiliary request 2.

4.4 As pointed out under point 2.6 above the skilled reader would consider the presence of

a) an actuator for the mechanical movement positioned apart from the turntable and including a pin;

b) a cog element consisting of an engaging element, a chain element and a release element; and

c) a controller actuating the pin for engaging the engaging element

as indispensable for providing a functioning apparatus according to the present invention having a packaging material holder isolated from any electrical or fluid power source by the rotatable turntable.

4.5 The above-mentioned features are not present in claim 18 according to the auxiliary request 2 and thus claim 18 of said request results from the extraction of isolated features from the specific feature's combination disclosed as essential in the single apparatus embodiment of the application as filed.

4.6 Since the appellant did not refer to other parts of the application as filed that could support the proposed amendment, nor have such parts been identified by the Board, claim 18 as amended in accordance with the auxiliary request 2 does not meet the requirements of Article 123(2) EPC.