Access our patent databases and search tools.
Go to overview
Join the Patent Knowledge Forum on 4 December 2024
Practical information on filing and grant procedures.
Find out how the Unitary Patent can enhance your IP strategy
European patent law, the Official Journal and other legal texts.
Deepen your IP knowledge: access our legal texts collection
Our latest news, podcasts and events, including the European Inventor Award.
From ideas to inventions: tune into our podcast for the latest in tech and IP
The European Patent Academy – the point of access to your learning
Boost your IP knowledge with (e-)training from the European Patent Academy
Find out more about our work, values, history and vision
Track the latest tech trends with our Patent Index
Overview
National decisions according to countries
AT – Austria
2011
Supreme Patent and Trademark Chamber of 29.06.2011 (Op 3/11)
144
2012
Supreme Patent and Trademark Chamber of 27.06.2012 (Op 1/12)
54
Board of Appeal of the Austrian Patent Office of 22.11.2012 (B 1/2011)
28
2013
Supreme Patent and Trademark Chamber of 27.02.2013 (Op 3/12)
93
Supreme Patent and Trademark Chamber of 08.05.2013 (OBp 2/13)
29
Supreme Patent and Trademark Chamber of 27.11.2013 (Op 3/13)
56
BE – Belgium
Mons Commercial Court of 03.11.2011 (A/10/792) – Valéo v Lexmond Trading
30
Mons Court of Appeal of 12 January 2012 (2011/RG/00402) – Malvern v Occhio
99
Liège Commercial Court of 28.06.2012 (A/11/3039) – Aerocrine v SA Medisoft
57
Mons Commercial Court of 21 February 2013 (RG A/09/663) – Occhio v Malvern
89
Liège Court of Appeal of 19.09.2013 (2011/RG/1503) – Saint-Gobain v Knauf
155
Antwerp District Court of 20.12.13 – Sandoz v AstraZeneca
135
DE – Germany
Federal Court of Justice of 24.02.2011 (X ZR 121/09) – Website display
11
Federal Court of Justice of 21.06.2011 (X ZR 43/09) – Integration element
101
Federal Court of Justice of 22.11.2011 (X ZR 58/10) – E-Mail via SMS
41
Federal Patent Court of 27.03.2012 (4 Ni 24/10) – Coffee machine
91
Federal Court of Justice of 15.05.2012 (X ZR 98/09)Calcipotriol monohydrate
149
Federal Court of Justice of 17.07.2012 (X ZR 117/11) – Polymer foam
94
Federal Court of Justice of 14.08.2012 (X ZR 3/10) – Non-UV-sensitive printing plate
117
Federal Patent Court of 13.11.2012, joined cases 3 Ni 43/10 (EP), 3 Ni 24/11 (EP), 3 Ni 25/11 (EP) – Quetiapine
136
Federal Court of Justice of 27.11.2012 (X ZR 58/07) – Neural progenitor cells II
21
Federal Court of Justice of 12.12.2012 (X ZR 134/11) – Polymer composition
66
Federal Court of Justice of 18.12.2012 (X ZR 3/12) – Route planning
58
Federal Patent Court of 04.04.2013 (2 Ni 59/11 and 2 Ni 64/11) – Slide to unlock
59
Federal Court of Justice of 09.04.2013 (X ZR 130/11) – Scrambling method
102
Federal Court of Justice of 23.04.2013 (X ZR 27/12) – Vehicle navigation system
61
Federal Court of Justice of 11.09.2013 (X ZB 8/12) – Dipeptidyl-peptidase inhibitors
79
Federal Court of Justice of 24.09.2013 (X ZR 40/12) – Fatty acids
36
Federal Court of Justice of 15.10.2013 (X ZR 41/11) – Image display device
31
2014
Federal Court of Justice of 11.02.2014 (X ZR 107/12) – Communication channel
119
Federal Court of Justice of 25.02.2014 (X ZB 5/13) – Collagenase I
37
Federal Court of Justice of 11.03.2014 (X ZR 139/10) – Paint supply system
43
2015
Federal Court of Justice of 13.01.2015 (X ZR 41/13) – Quetiapine
138
DK – Denmark
Danish High Court of 25.05.2012 – Danisco A/S (today a part of DuPont) v Novozymes A/S
132
ES – Spain
Supreme Court (Civil Chamber) of 27.04.2011 – LEK Pharma v Warnre- Lambert – Atorvastatina (274/2011)
160
Supreme Court (Civil Chamber) of 10.05.2012 – Laboratorios Cinfa et al. v Eli Lilly and Co Ltd(309/2011)
178
Court of Appeal of Madrid (Section 28) of 04.03.2013 – Actavis Group et al. v Merck Sharp & Dohme (17/2013)
159
Court of Appeal of Barcelona (Section 15) of 24.07.2014 – Merck & Co. v Laboratorios Alter et al. (Auto 93/2014)
161
FR – France
Court of Cassation of 02.11.2011 [10-30907] – Groupe Vicard SA v Tonnellerie Ludonnaise SA
44
Court of Cassation of 29.11.2011 [10-24786] – Negma v Biogaran
35
Court of Cassation of 13.12.2011 [10-27413] – SAS Technip France v SA ITP
Paris Court of Appeal of 13.01.2012 (10/17727) – Sandoz v Eli Lilly
67
Court of Cassation of 31.01.2012 [11-10924] – Go sport v Time Sport international
120
Paris District Court of 20.03.2012 (09/12706) – Teva v Eli Lilly
73
Paris Court of Appeal of 21.03.2012 (09/23852) – Arcelormittal v Voestalpine
80
Paris Court of Appeal of 23.03.2012 (10/22368) – VSL International v Freyssinet International
81
Court of Cassation of 03.04.2012 [10-21084] – M. G v R
162
Court of Cassation of 20.11.2012 [11-18440] – Boegli gravures v Darsail
69
Paris Court of Appeal of 26.04.2013 (12/07634) – Core/Miral v Axxom/Castorama/Browaeys Brame
62
Paris Court of Appeal of 7.06.2013 (10/15598) – Security of Documents (Sood) v European Central Bank (ECB)
104
Paris Court of Appeal of 28.06.2013 (10/21790) – Mr L. v Publicis Groupe & RATP
12
Paris Court of Appeal of 03.07.2013 (10/22679) – Sotira v CPO
163
Paris Court of Appeal of 25.10.2013 (13/06455) – Syngenta v INPI Director General
106
Paris Court of Appeal of 20.12.2013 (12/14147) – Icotex v Saertex
108
Paris Court of Appeal of 12.02.2014 (12/16589) – Anne D v Sarl AD / Hermès Sellier SA
45
Paris District Court of 13.02.2014 (13/00455) – Virbac v Merial
92
Paris Court of Appeal of 12.03.2014 (12/07203) – Eli Lilly v Teva
39
Paris Court of appeal of 19.03.2014 (10/21042) – Artygraphie c. Cartel
13
Paris Court of Appeal of 16.05.2014 (12/06678) – Knauf c. St Gobain
156
Court of Cassation of 20.05.2014 [13-10061] – X v Sig Sauer
98
Paris District Court of 3.07.2014 (10/14406) – Evinerude v Aair Lichens
15
GB – United Kingdom
Supreme Court of 01.11.2011 – Human Genome Sciences Inc v eli Lilly & Co. [2011] UKSC 51
Patents Court of 15.12.2011 – Sandvik Intellectual Property AB v (1) Kennametal UK Ltd, (2) Kennametal European GmbH [2011] EWHC 3311 (Pat)
83
Patents Court of 22.03.2012 – Teva UK Ltd v AstraZeneca AB [2012] EWHC 655 (Pat)
139
England and Wales Court of Appeal of 10.05.2012 – Nokia OYJ v IPCom GmbH & Co KG [2012] EWCA Civ 567
110
Patents Court of 27.07.2012 – Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd v Contour Aerospace Ltd and others [2012] EWHC 2153 (Pat)
46
164
Court of Appeal of 05.09.2012 – Eli Lily & Co v Human Genome Sciences (HGS) Inc [2012] EWCA Civ 1185
86
Court of Appeal of 10.10.2012 – MedImmune Ltd v Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Ltd [2012] EWCA Civ 1234
48
123
Court of Appeal of 12.12.2012 – Novartis AG v Generics (UK) Ltd [2012] EWCA Civ 1623
51
Patents Court of 07.03.2013 – Samsung electronics Co Ltd v Apple Retail UK Ltd and anr [2013] EWC 467 (Pat)
124
Patents Court of 17.04.2013 – International Stem Cell Corporation v Comptroller General of Patents [2013] EWHC 807 (Ch)
23
Patents Court of 22.04.2013 – Nestec S.A. v Dualit Ltd [2013] EWHC 923 (Pat)
126
Court of Appeal of 30.04.2013 – AstraZeneca AB v Hexal [2013] EWCA Civ 454
141
Court of Appeal of 03.05.2013 – HTC v Apple [2013] EWCA Civ 451
16
Supreme Court of 03.07.2013 – Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd v Zodiac Seats UK Ltd [2013] UKSC 46
168
Patents Court of 10.07.2013 – HTC Corporation v Gemalto SA and HTC Corporation v Gemalto NV [2013] EWHC 1876 (Pat)
122
129
Court of Appeal of 29.07.2013 – Generics [UK] Ltd t/a Mylan v Yeda Research and Development Co Ltd and Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 925
63
Patents Court of 04.09.2013 – Lantana Ltd v Comptroller General of Patents [2013] EWHC 2673 (Pat)
19
Court of Appeal of 21.11.2013 – IPCom GmbH v HTC Co Europe Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 1496
170
Court of Appeal of 20.12.2013 – Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd v Zodiac Seats UK Ld (formerly Contour Aerospace Ltd) and others [2013] EWCA Civ 1713
Court of Appeal of 28.01.2014 – AP Racing Ltd v Alcon Components Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 40
113
Court of Appeal of 11.03.2014 – Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Apple Retail UK Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 250
173
Patents Court of 20.06.2014 – Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Nintendo of Europe GmbH [2014] EWHC 1959 (Pat)
74
Patents Court of 11 and 24.07.2014 – Actavis Group PTC EHF v Pharmacia LLC [2014] EWHC 2265 (Pat) and [2014] EWHC 2611 (Pat), respectively
175
Patents Court of 22.07.2014 -AgaMedical Corporation v Occlutech (UK) Ltd [2014] EWHC 2506 (Pat)
32
IT – Italy
Turin Ordinary Court of 11.02.2011 – Sandoz v Leo Pharma – calcipotriol monohydrate
150
NL – Netherlands
Rechtbank 'S-Gravenhage of 22.06.2011 – Danisco v Novozymes
133
The Hague Court of Appeal of 27.09.2011 – Eli Lilly v Ratiopharm
145
Supreme Court of 25.05.2012 – Aga v Occlutech
146
The Hague Regional Court of Appeal of 09.04.2013 – Sandoz v Leo Pharma
151
The Hague District Court of 08.05.2013 – Taste of Nature Holding B.V. v Cresco Handels-B.V.
26
Supreme Court of 07.06.2013 – Lundbeck v Tiefenbacher/Centrafarm – Escitalopram
53
The Hague District Court of 19.12.2013 – Unilever N.V. v Procter & Gamble
167
Supreme Court of 04.04.2014 – Medinol v Abbott
96
The Hague Regional Court of 10.06.2014 – Accord v AstraZeneca
142
NO – Norway
Borgarting Court of Appeal of 06.01.2014 – STS Gruppen AS v Stillasgruppen AS and Stillastjenester
115
Borgarting Court of Appeal of 24.01.2014 – Krka v Astrazeneca –Esomeprazole
97
SE – Sweden
District Court of Stockholm of 04.03.2011 – Occlutech GmbH v AGA Medical Corporation, AGA Medical Corporation v Occlutech International AB and Tor Peters (Joint cases)
148
District Court of Stockholm of 20.05.2011 – Leo v Sandoz
153
