Skip to main content Skip to footer
HomeHome
 
  • Homepage
  • Searching for patents

    Patent knowledge

    Access our patent databases and search tools.

    Go to overview 

    • Overview
    • Technical information
      • Overview
      • Espacenet - patent search
      • European Publication Server
      • EP full-text search
    • Legal information
      • Overview
      • European Patent Register
      • European Patent Bulletin
      • European Case Law Identifier sitemap
      • Third-party observations
    • Business information
      • Overview
      • PATSTAT
      • IPscore
      • Technology insight reports
    • Data
      • Overview
      • Technology Intelligence Platform
      • Linked open EP data
      • Bulk data sets
      • Web services
      • Coverage, codes and statistics
    • Technology platforms
      • Overview
      • Plastics in transition
      • Water innovation
      • Space innovation
      • Technologies combatting cancer
      • Firefighting technologies
      • Clean energy technologies
      • Fighting coronavirus
    • Helpful resources
      • Overview
      • First time here?
      • Asian patent information
      • Patent information centres
      • Patent Translate
      • Patent Knowledge News
      • Business and statistics
      • Unitary Patent information in patent knowledge
    Image
    Plastics in Transition

    Technology insight report on plastic waste management

  • Applying for a patent

    Applying for a patent

    Practical information on filing and grant procedures.

    Go to overview 

    • Overview
    • European route
      • Overview
      • European Patent Guide
      • Oppositions
      • Oral proceedings
      • Appeals
      • Unitary Patent & Unified Patent Court
      • National validation
      • Request for extension/validation
    • International route (PCT)
      • Overview
      • Euro-PCT Guide – PCT procedure at the EPO
      • EPO decisions and notices
      • PCT provisions and resources
      • Extension/validation request
      • Reinforced partnership programme
      • Accelerating your PCT application
      • Patent Prosecution Highway (PPH)
      • Training and events
    • National route
    • Find a professional representative
    • MyEPO services
      • Overview
      • Understand our services
      • Get access
      • File with us
      • Interact with us on your files
      • Online Filing & fee payment outages
    • Forms
      • Overview
      • Request for examination
    • Fees
      • Overview
      • European fees (EPC)
      • International fees (PCT)
      • Unitary Patent fees (UP)
      • Fee payment and refunds
      • Warning

    UP

    Find out how the Unitary Patent can enhance your IP strategy

  • Law & practice

    Law & practice

    European patent law, the Official Journal and other legal texts.

    Go to overview 

    • Overview
    • Legal texts
      • Overview
      • European Patent Convention
      • Official Journal
      • Guidelines
      • Extension / validation system
      • London Agreement
      • National law relating to the EPC
      • Unitary patent system
      • National measures relating to the Unitary Patent
    • Court practices
      • Overview
      • European Patent Judges' Symposium
    • User consultations
      • Overview
      • Ongoing consultations
      • Completed consultations
    • Substantive patent law harmonisation
      • Overview
      • The Tegernsee process
      • Group B+
    • Convergence of practice
    • Options for professional representatives
    Image
    Law and practice scales 720x237

    Keep up with key aspects of selected BoA decisions with our monthly "Abstracts of decisions”

  • News & events

    News & events

    Our latest news, podcasts and events, including the European Inventor Award.

    Go to overview 

     

    • Overview
    • News
    • Events
    • European Inventor Award
      • Overview
      • The meaning of tomorrow
      • About the award
      • Categories and prizes
      • Meet the finalists
      • Nominations
      • European Inventor Network
      • The 2024 event
    • Young Inventor Prize
      • Overview
      • About the prize
      • Nominations
      • The jury
      • The world, reimagined
    • Press centre
      • Overview
      • Patent Index and statistics
      • Search in press centre
      • Background information
      • Copyright
      • Press contacts
      • Call back form
      • Email alert service
    • Innovation and patenting in focus
      • Overview
      • Water-related technologies
      • CodeFest
      • Green tech in focus
      • Research institutes
      • Women inventors
      • Lifestyle
      • Space and satellites
      • The future of medicine
      • Materials science
      • Mobile communications
      • Biotechnology
      • Patent classification
      • Digital technologies
      • The future of manufacturing
      • Books by EPO experts
    • "Talk innovation" podcast

    Podcast

    From ideas to inventions: tune into our podcast for the latest in tech and IP

  • Learning

    Learning

    The European Patent Academy – the point of access to your learning

    Go to overview 

    • Overview
    • Learning activities and paths
      • Overview
      • Learning activities
      • Learning paths
    • EQE and EPAC
      • Overview
      • EQE - European qualifying examination
      • EPAC - European patent administration certification
      • CSP – Candidate Support Programme
    • Learning resources by area of interest
      • Overview
      • Patent granting
      • Technology transfer and dissemination
      • Patent enforcement and litigation
    • Learning resources by profile
      • Overview
      • Business and IP managers
      • EQE and EPAC Candidates
      • Judges, lawyers and prosecutors
      • National offices and IP authorities
      • Patent attorneys and paralegals
      • Universities, research centres and technology transfer centres (TTOs)
    Image
    Patent Academy catalogue

    Have a look at the extensive range of learning opportunities in the European Patent Academy training catalogue

  • About us

    About us

    Find out more about our work, values, history and vision

    Go to overview 

    • Overview
    • The EPO at a glance
    • 50 years of the EPC
      • Overview
      • Official celebrations
      • Member states’ video statements
      • 50 Leading Tech Voices
      • Athens Marathon
      • Kids’ collaborative art competition
    • Legal foundations and member states
      • Overview
      • Legal foundations
      • Member states of the European Patent Organisation
      • Extension states
      • Validation states
    • Administrative Council and subsidiary bodies
      • Overview
      • Communiqués
      • Calendar
      • Documents and publications
      • Administrative Council
    • Principles & strategy
      • Overview
      • Our mission, vision, values and corporate policy
      • Strategic Plan 2028
      • Towards a New Normal
    • Leadership & management
      • Overview
      • President António Campinos
      • Management Advisory Committee
    • Sustainability at the EPO
      • Overview
      • Environmental
      • Social
      • Governance and Financial sustainability
    • Services & activities
      • Overview
      • Our services & structure
      • Quality
      • Consulting our users
      • European and international co-operation
      • European Patent Academy
      • Chief Economist
      • Ombuds Office
      • Reporting wrongdoing
    • Observatory on Patents and Technology
      • Overview
      • Innovation actors
      • Policy and funding
      • Tools
      • About the Observatory
    • Procurement
      • Overview
      • Procurement forecast
      • Doing business with the EPO
      • Procurement procedures
      • Sustainable Procurement Policy
      • About eTendering and electronic signatures
      • Procurement portal
      • Invoicing
      • General conditions
      • Archived tenders
    • Transparency portal
      • Overview
      • General
      • Human
      • Environmental
      • Organisational
      • Social and relational
      • Economic
      • Governance
    • Statistics and trends
      • Overview
      • Statistics & Trends Centre
      • Patent Index 2024
      • EPO Data Hub
      • Clarification on data sources
    • History
      • Overview
      • 1970s
      • 1980s
      • 1990s
      • 2000s
      • 2010s
      • 2020s
    • Art collection
      • Overview
      • The collection
      • Let's talk about art
      • Artists
      • Media library
      • What's on
      • Publications
      • Contact
      • Culture Space A&T 5-10
      • "Long Night"
    Image
    Patent Index 2024 keyvisual showing brightly lit up data chip, tinted in purple, bright blue

    Track the latest tech trends with our Patent Index

 
Website
cancel
en de fr
  • Language selection
  • English
  • Deutsch
  • Français
Main navigation
  • Homepage
    • Go back
    • New to patents
  • New to patents
    • Go back
    • Your business and patents
    • Why do we have patents?
    • What's your big idea?
    • Are you ready?
    • What to expect
    • How to apply for a patent
    • Is it patentable?
    • Are you first?
    • Patent quiz
    • Unitary patent video
  • Searching for patents
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • Technical information
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Espacenet - patent search
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • National patent office databases
        • Global Patent Index (GPI)
        • Release notes
      • European Publication Server
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Release notes
        • Cross-reference index for Euro-PCT applications
        • EP authority file
        • Help
      • EP full-text search
    • Legal information
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • European Patent Register
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Release notes archive
        • Register documentation
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Deep link data coverage
          • Federated Register
          • Register events
      • European Patent Bulletin
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Download Bulletin
        • EP Bulletin search
        • Help
      • European Case Law Identifier sitemap
      • Third-party observations
    • Business information
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • PATSTAT
      • IPscore
        • Go back
        • Release notes
      • Technology insight reports
    • Data
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Technology Intelligence Platform
      • Linked open EP data
      • Bulk data sets
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Manuals
        • Sequence listings
        • National full-text data
        • European Patent Register data
        • EPO worldwide bibliographic data (DOCDB)
        • EP full-text data
        • EPO worldwide legal event data (INPADOC)
        • EP bibliographic data (EBD)
        • Boards of Appeal decisions
      • Web services
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Open Patent Services (OPS)
        • European Publication Server web service
      • Coverage, codes and statistics
        • Go back
        • Weekly updates
        • Updated regularly
    • Technology platforms
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Plastics in transition
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Plastics waste recovery
        • Plastics waste recycling
        • Alternative plastics
      • Innovation in water technologies
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Clean water
        • Protection from water
      • Space innovation
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Cosmonautics
        • Space observation
      • Technologies combatting cancer
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Prevention and early detection
        • Diagnostics
        • Therapies
        • Wellbeing and aftercare
      • Firefighting technologies
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Detection and prevention of fires
        • Fire extinguishing
        • Protective equipment
        • Post-fire restoration
      • Clean energy technologies
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Renewable energy
        • Carbon-intensive industries
        • Energy storage and other enabling technologies
      • Fighting coronavirus
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Vaccines and therapeutics
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Vaccines
          • Overview of candidate therapies for COVID-19
          • Candidate antiviral and symptomatic therapeutics
          • Nucleic acids and antibodies to fight coronavirus
        • Diagnostics and analytics
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Protein and nucleic acid assays
          • Analytical protocols
        • Informatics
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Bioinformatics
          • Healthcare informatics
        • Technologies for the new normal
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Devices, materials and equipment
          • Procedures, actions and activities
          • Digital technologies
        • Inventors against coronavirus
    • Helpful resources
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • First time here?
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Basic definitions
        • Patent classification
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC)
        • Patent families
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • DOCDB simple patent family
          • INPADOC extended patent family
        • Legal event data
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • INPADOC classification scheme
      • Asian patent information
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • China (CN)
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Facts and figures
          • Grant procedure
          • Numbering system
          • Useful terms
          • Searching in databases
        • Chinese Taipei (TW)
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Grant procedure
          • Numbering system
          • Useful terms
          • Searching in databases
        • India (IN)
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Facts and figures
          • Grant procedure
          • Numbering system
        • Japan (JP)
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Facts and figures
          • Grant procedure
          • Numbering system
          • Useful terms
          • Searching in databases
        • Korea (KR)
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Facts and figures
          • Grant procedure
          • Numbering system
          • Useful terms
          • Searching in databases
        • Russian Federation (RU)
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Facts and figures
          • Numbering system
          • Searching in databases
        • Useful links
      • Patent information centres (PATLIB)
      • Patent Translate
      • Patent Knowledge News
      • Business and statistics
      • Unitary Patent information in patent knowledge
  • Applying for a patent
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • European route
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • European Patent Guide
      • Oppositions
      • Oral proceedings
        • Go back
        • Oral proceedings calendar
          • Go back
          • Calendar
          • Public access to appeal proceedings
          • Public access to opposition proceedings
          • Technical guidelines
      • Appeals
      • Unitary Patent & Unified Patent Court
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Unitary Patent
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Legal framework
          • Main features
          • Applying for a Unitary Patent
          • Cost of a Unitary Patent
          • Translation and compensation
          • Start date
          • Introductory brochures
        • Unified Patent Court
      • National validation
      • Extension/validation request
    • International route
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Euro-PCT Guide
      • Entry into the European phase
      • Decisions and notices
      • PCT provisions and resources
      • Extension/validation request
      • Reinforced partnership programme
      • Accelerating your PCT application
      • Patent Prosecution Highway (PPH)
        • Go back
        • Patent Prosecution Highway (PPH) programme outline
      • Training and events
    • National route
    • MyEPO services
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Understand our services
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Exchange data with us using an API
          • Go back
          • Release notes
      • Get access
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Release notes
      • File with us
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • What if our online filing services are down?
        • Release notes
      • Interact with us on your files
        • Go back
        • Release notes
      • Online Filing & fee payment outages
    • Fees
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • European fees (EPC)
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Decisions and notices
      • International fees (PCT)
        • Go back
        • Reduction in fees
        • Fees for international applications
        • Decisions and notices
        • Overview
      • Unitary Patent fees (UP)
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Decisions and notices
      • Fee payment and refunds
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Payment methods
        • Getting started
        • FAQs and other documentation
        • Technical information for batch payments
        • Decisions and notices
        • Release notes
      • Warning
    • Forms
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Request for examination
    • Find a professional representative
  • Law & practice
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • Legal texts
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • European Patent Convention
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Archive
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Documentation on the EPC revision 2000
            • Go back
            • Overview
            • Diplomatic Conference for the revision of the EPC
            • Travaux préparatoires
            • New text
            • Transitional provisions
            • Implementing regulations to the EPC 2000
            • Rules relating to Fees
            • Ratifications and accessions
          • Travaux Préparatoires EPC 1973
      • Official Journal
      • Guidelines
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • EPC Guidelines
        • PCT-EPO Guidelines
        • Unitary Patent Guidelines
        • Guidelines revision cycle
        • Consultation results
        • Summary of user responses
        • Archive
      • Extension / validation system
      • London Agreement
      • National law relating to the EPC
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Archive
      • Unitary Patent system
        • Go back
        • Travaux préparatoires to UP and UPC
      • National measures relating to the Unitary Patent 
    • Court practices
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • European Patent Judges' Symposium
    • User consultations
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Ongoing consultations
      • Completed consultations
    • Substantive patent law harmonisation
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • The Tegernsee process
      • Group B+
    • Convergence of practice
    • Options for professional representatives
  • News & events
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • News
    • Events
    • European Inventor Award
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • The meaning of tomorrow
      • About the award
      • Categories and prizes
      • Meet the inventors
      • Nominations
      • European Inventor Network
        • Go back
        • 2024 activities
        • 2025 activities
        • Rules and criteria
        • FAQ
      • The 2024 event
    • Young Inventors Prize
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • About the prize
      • Nominations
      • The jury
      • The world, reimagined
      • The 2025 event
    • Press centre
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Patent Index and statistics
      • Search in press centre
      • Background information
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • European Patent Office
        • Q&A on patents related to coronavirus
        • Q&A on plant patents
      • Copyright
      • Press contacts
      • Call back form
      • Email alert service
    • In focus
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Water-related technologies
      • CodeFest
        • Go back
        • CodeFest Spring 2025 on classifying patent data for sustainable development
        • Overview
        • CodeFest 2024 on generative AI
        • CodeFest 2023 on Green Plastics
      • Green tech in focus
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • About green tech
        • Renewable energies
        • Energy transition technologies
        • Building a greener future
      • Research institutes
      • Women inventors
      • Lifestyle
      • Space and satellites
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Patents and space technologies
      • Healthcare
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Medical technologies and cancer
        • Personalised medicine
      • Materials science
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Nanotechnology
      • Mobile communications
      • Biotechnology
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Red, white or green
        • The role of the EPO
        • What is patentable?
        • Biotech inventors
      • Classification
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Nanotechnology
        • Climate change mitigation technologies
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • External partners
          • Updates on Y02 and Y04S
      • Digital technologies
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • About ICT
        • Hardware and software
        • Artificial intelligence
        • Fourth Industrial Revolution
      • Additive manufacturing
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • About AM
        • AM innovation
      • Books by EPO experts
    • Podcast
  • Learning
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • Learning activities and paths
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Learning activities: types and formats
      • Learning paths
    • EQE and EPAC
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • EQE - European Qualifying Examination
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Compendium
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Paper F
          • Paper A
          • Paper B
          • Paper C
          • Paper D
          • Pre-examination
        • Candidates successful in the European qualifying examination
        • Archive
      • EPAC - European patent administration certification
      • CSP – Candidate Support Programme
    • Learning resources by area of interest
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Patent granting
      • Technology transfer and dissemination
      • Patent enforcement and litigation
    • Learning resources by profile
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Business and IP managers
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Innovation case studies
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • SME case studies
          • Technology transfer case studies
          • High-growth technology case studies
        • Inventor's handbook
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Introduction
          • Disclosure and confidentiality
          • Novelty and prior art
          • Competition and market potential
          • Assessing the risk ahead
          • Proving the invention
          • Protecting your idea
          • Building a team and seeking funding
          • Business planning
          • Finding and approaching companies
          • Dealing with companies
        • Best of search matters
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Tools and databases
          • EPO procedures and initiatives
          • Search strategies
          • Challenges and specific topics
        • Support for high-growth technology businesses
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Business decision-makers
          • IP professionals
          • Stakeholders of the Innovation Ecosystem
      • EQE and EPAC Candidates
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Paper F brain-teasers
        • Daily D questions
        • European qualifying examination - Guide for preparation
        • EPAC
      • Judges, lawyers and prosecutors
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Compulsory licensing in Europe
        • The jurisdiction of European courts in patent disputes
      • National offices and IP authorities
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Learning material for examiners of national officers
        • Learning material for formalities officers and paralegals
      • Patent attorneys and paralegals
      • Universities, research centres and TTOs
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Modular IP Education Framework (MIPEF)
        • Pan-European Seal Young Professionals Programme
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • For students
          • For universities
            • Go back
            • Overview
            • IP education resources
            • University memberships
          • Our young professionals
          • Professional development plan
        • Academic Research Programme
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Completed research projects
          • Current research projects
        • IP Teaching Kit
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Download modules
        • Intellectual property course design manual
        • PATLIB Knowledge Transfer to Africa
          • Go back
          • The PATLIB Knowledge Transfer to Africa initiative (KT2A)
          • KT2A core activities
          • Success story: Malawi University of Science and Technology and PATLIB Birmingham
  • About us
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • The EPO at a glance
    • 50 years of the EPC
      • Go back
      • Official celebrations
      • Overview
      • Member states’ video statements
        • Go back
        • Albania
        • Austria
        • Belgium
        • Bulgaria
        • Croatia
        • Cyprus
        • Czech Republic
        • Denmark
        • Estonia
        • Finland
        • France
        • Germany
        • Greece
        • Hungary
        • Iceland
        • Ireland
        • Italy
        • Latvia
        • Liechtenstein
        • Lithuania
        • Luxembourg
        • Malta
        • Monaco
        • Montenegro
        • Netherlands
        • North Macedonia
        • Norway
        • Poland
        • Portugal
        • Romania
        • San Marino
        • Serbia
        • Slovakia
        • Slovenia
        • Spain
        • Sweden
        • Switzerland
        • Türkiye
        • United Kingdom
      • 50 Leading Tech Voices
      • Athens Marathon
      • Kids’ collaborative art competition
    • Legal foundations and member states
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Legal foundations
      • Member states
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Member states by date of accession
      • Extension states
      • Validation states
    • Administrative Council and subsidiary bodies
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Communiqués
        • Go back
        • 2024
        • Overview
        • 2023
        • 2022
        • 2021
        • 2020
        • 2019
        • 2018
        • 2017
        • 2016
        • 2015
        • 2014
        • 2013
      • Calendar
      • Documents and publications
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Select Committee documents
      • Administrative Council
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Composition
        • Representatives
        • Rules of Procedure
        • Board of Auditors
        • Secretariat
        • Council bodies
    • Principles & strategy
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Mission, vision, values & corporate policy
      • Strategic Plan 2028
        • Go back
        • Driver 1: People
        • Driver 2: Technologies
        • Driver 3: High-quality, timely products and services
        • Driver 4: Partnerships
        • Driver 5: Financial sustainability
      • Towards a New Normal
      • Data protection & privacy notice
    • Leadership & management
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • About the President
      • Management Advisory Committee
    • Sustainability at the EPO
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Environmental
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Inspiring environmental inventions
      • Social
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Inspiring social inventions
      • Governance and Financial sustainability
    • Procurement
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Procurement forecast
      • Doing business with the EPO
      • Procurement procedures
      • Dynamic Purchasing System (DPS) publications
      • Sustainable Procurement Policy
      • About eTendering
      • Invoicing
      • Procurement portal
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • e-Signing contracts
      • General conditions
      • Archived tenders
    • Services & activities
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Our services & structure
      • Quality
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Foundations
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • European Patent Convention
          • Guidelines for examination
          • Our staff
        • Enabling quality
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Prior art
          • Classification
          • Tools
          • Processes
        • Products & services
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Search
          • Examination
          • Opposition
          • Continuous improvement
        • Quality through networking
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • User engagement
          • Co-operation
          • User satisfaction survey
          • Stakeholder Quality Assurance Panels
        • Patent Quality Charter
        • Quality Action Plan
        • Quality dashboard
        • Statistics
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Search
          • Examination
          • Opposition
        • Integrated management at the EPO
      • Consulting our users
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Standing Advisory Committee before the EPO (SACEPO)
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Objectives
          • SACEPO and its working parties
          • Meetings
          • Single Access Portal – SACEPO Area
        • Surveys
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Detailed methodology
          • Search services
          • Examination services, final actions and publication
          • Opposition services
          • Formalities services
          • Customer services
          • Filing services
          • Key Account Management (KAM)
          • Website
          • Archive
      • Our user service charter
      • European and international co-operation
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Co-operation with member states
          • Go back
          • Overview
        • Bilateral co-operation with non-member states
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Validation system
          • Reinforced Partnership programme
        • Multilateral international co-operation with IP offices and organisations
        • Co-operation with international organisations outside the IP system
      • European Patent Academy
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Partners
      • Chief Economist
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Economic studies
      • Ombuds Office
      • Reporting wrongdoing
    • Observatory on Patents and Technology
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Innovation against cancer
      • Innovation actors
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Startups and SMEs
      • Policy and funding
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Financing innovation programme
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Our studies on the financing of innovation
          • EPO initiatives for patent applicants
          • Financial support for innovators in Europe
        • Patents and standards
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Publications
          • Patent standards explorer
      • Tools
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Deep Tech Finder
      • About the Observatory
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Work plan
    • Transparency portal
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • General
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Annual Review 2023
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Foreword
          • Executive summary
          • 50 years of the EPC
          • Strategic key performance indicators
          • Goal 1: Engaged and empowered
          • Goal 2: Digital transformation
          • Goal 3: Master quality
          • Goal 4: Partner for positive impact
          • Goal 5: Secure sustainability
        • Annual Review 2022
          • Go back
          • Overview
          • Foreword
          • Executive summary
          • Goal 1: Engaged and empowered
          • Goal 2: Digital transformation
          • Goal 3: Master quality
          • Goal 4: Partner for positive impact
          • Goal 5: Secure sustainability
      • Human
      • Environmental
      • Organisational
      • Social and relational
      • Economic
      • Governance
    • Statistics and trends
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Statistics & Trends Centre
      • Patent Index 2024
        • Go back
        • Insight into computer technology and AI
        • Insight into clean energy technologies
        • Statistics and indicators
          • Go back
          • European patent applications
            • Go back
            • Key trend
            • Origin
            • Top 10 technical fields
              • Go back
              • Computer technology
              • Electrical machinery, apparatus, energy
              • Digital communication
              • Medical technology
              • Transport
              • Measurement
              • Biotechnology
              • Pharmaceuticals
              • Other special machines
              • Organic fine chemistry
            • All technical fields
          • Applicants
            • Go back
            • Top 50
            • Categories
            • Women inventors
          • Granted patents
            • Go back
            • Key trend
            • Origin
            • Designations
      • Data to download
      • EPO Data Hub
      • Clarification on data sources
    • History
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • 1970s
      • 1980s
      • 1990s
      • 2000s
      • 2010s
      • 2020s
    • Art collection
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • The collection
      • Let's talk about art
      • Artists
      • Media library
      • What's on
      • Publications
      • Contact
      • Culture Space A&T 5-10
        • Go back
        • Catalyst lab & Deep vision
          • Go back
          • Irene Sauter (DE)
          • AVPD (DK)
          • Jan Robert Leegte (NL)
          • Jānis Dzirnieks (LV) #1
          • Jānis Dzirnieks (LV) #2
          • Péter Szalay (HU)
          • Thomas Feuerstein (AT)
          • Tom Burr (US)
          • Wolfgang Tillmans (DE)
          • TerraPort
          • Unfinished Sculpture - Captives #1
          • Deep vision – immersive exhibition
          • Previous exhibitions
        • The European Patent Journey
        • Sustaining life. Art in the climate emergency
        • Next generation statements
        • Open storage
        • Cosmic bar
      • "Long Night"
  • Boards of Appeal
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • Decisions of the Boards of Appeal
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Recent decisions
      • Selected decisions
    • Information from the Boards of Appeal
    • Procedure
    • Oral proceedings
    • About the Boards of Appeal
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • President of the Boards of Appeal
      • Enlarged Board of Appeal
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Pending referrals (Art. 112 EPC)
        • Decisions sorted by number (Art. 112 EPC)
        • Pending petitions for review (Art. 112a EPC)
        • Decisions on petitions for review (Art. 112a EPC)
      • Technical Boards of Appeal
      • Legal Board of Appeal
      • Disciplinary Board of Appeal
      • Presidium
        • Go back
        • Overview
    • Code of Conduct
    • Business distribution scheme
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Technical boards of appeal by IPC in 2025
      • Archive
    • Annual list of cases
    • Communications
    • Annual reports
      • Go back
      • Overview
    • Publications
      • Go back
      • Abstracts of decisions
    • Case Law of the Boards of Appeal
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Archive
  • Service & support
    • Go back
    • Overview
    • Website updates
    • Availability of online services
      • Go back
      • Overview
    • FAQ
      • Go back
      • Overview
    • Publications
    • Ordering
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Patent Knowledge Products and Services
      • Terms and conditions
        • Go back
        • Overview
        • Patent information products
        • Bulk data sets
        • Open Patent Services (OPS)
        • Fair use charter
    • Procedural communications
    • Useful links
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Patent offices of member states
      • Other patent offices
      • Directories of patent attorneys
      • Patent databases, registers and gazettes
      • Disclaimer
    • Contact us
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Filing options
      • Locations
    • Subscription centre
      • Go back
      • Overview
      • Subscribe
      • Change preferences
      • Unsubscribe
    • Official holidays
    • Glossary
    • RSS feeds
Board of Appeals
Decisions

Recent decisions

Overview
  • 2025 decisions
  • 2024 decisions
  • 2023 decisions
  1. Home
  2. T 1072/93 18-09-1997
Facebook X Linkedin Email

T 1072/93 18-09-1997

European Case Law Identifier
ECLI:EP:BA:1997:T107293.19970918
Date of decision
18 September 1997
Case number
T 1072/93
Petition for review of
-
Application number
86900396.2
IPC class
B23B 27/30
Language of proceedings
EN
Distribution
DISTRIBUTED TO BOARD CHAIRMEN (C)

Download and more information:

Decision in EN 657.76 KB
Documentation of the appeal procedure can be found in the European Patent Register
Bibliographic information is available in:
EN
Versions
Unpublished
Application title

Irradiated multilayer film for primal meat packaging

Applicant name
VISKASE CORPORATION
Opponent name

W.R. Grace & Co.

Dixie Union Verpackungen GmbH

Board
3.3.03
Headnote
-
Relevant legal provisions
European Patent Convention Art 84 1973
Keywords

Clarity (no) - claims amended at oral proceedings - a number of adjournments

Claims clearly unallowable - no alternative but to decide finally

Judicial function of Board precludes too much assistance to either party

Catchword
-
Cited decisions
-
Citing decisions
T 0079/01
T 1109/18
T 1756/11

I. The mention of the grant of European patent No. 0 202 308, entitled "Irradiated multilayer film for primal meat packaging", in respect of European patent application No. 86 900 396.2, corresponding to International Application No. PCT/US85/02352, and claiming a US priority of 3 December 1984 (US 677362) was announced on 3 April 1991 (Bulletin 91/14), on the basis of a set of 18 claims. The independent claims of this set were directed to a heat-shrinkable, multilayer film (Claim 1) and to a process for producing such a multilayer film (Claim 16), respectively.

II. Two Notices of Opposition were filed, both on 2 January 1992, on the grounds of Article 100(a) EPC, that the subject-matter claimed in the patent in suit did not involve an inventive step. In reply to these Notices of Opposition, the Patentee defended the patent first of all in its form as granted (submission filed on 5. August 1992, with a letter dated 31 July 1992), and then, in preparation for oral proceedings to be held before the Opposition Division, also on the basis of a new set of claims forming an auxiliary request, filed on 25 August 1993 (submission dated 23 August 1993). The latter set was replaced with a further set of claims filed on 1 September 1993 (letter of same date). At the oral proceedings held before the Opposition Division on 8 September 1993, the Patentee presented, following an invitation of the Chairman, a first amended main request together with a first auxiliary request and a second auxiliary request, after which he decided to file a new main request together with a sole auxiliary request (minutes of oral proceedings before the Opposition Division, point 3).

Claim 1 of this sole auxiliary request read as follows:

"A coextruded heat shrinkable, three layer film comprising a first outer layer comprising a first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, a core layer comprising a barrier film formed of a polyvinylidene chloride copolymer containing at least 65 weight percent of polyvinylidene chloride based on the weight of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer, with the remainder of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer being selected from the group consisting of vinyl chloride, acrylonitrile, and acrylate esters, and a second outer layer comprising a second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer wherein said coextruded three layer film has been biaxially stretched and then irradiated to a dosage level of between 1·104 Gy and 4·104 Gy (1 and 4 megarads) as the sole irradiation treatment, so as to induce crosslinking."

Claims 2 to 13 were dependent claims directed to elaborations of the film according to Claim 1.

Claim 14, an independent claim, read as follows:

"A process for producing a three layer film according to any one of claims 1 to 13 comprising:

(a) co-extruding a first outer film layer comprising a first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, a core film layer comprising a barrier film, and a second outer film layer comprising a second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer;

(b) biaxially stretching said film; and

(c) irradiating said film to a dosage level of between 1·104 Gy and 4·104 Gy (1 and 4 megarads), as the sole irradiation treatment, so as to induce crosslinking."

Claims 15 and 16 were dependent claims directed to elaborations of the process of Claim 14.

III. By a decision taken at the oral proceedings, on the basis inter alia of the set of Claims 1 to 16 forming the sole auxiliary request, and issued in writing on 27. October 1993, the Opposition Division revoked the patent, since it did not meet the requirements of the EPC, in particular Articles 52 and 56.

IV. On 20 December 1993, a Notice of Appeal was filed against the above decision by the Patentee (Appellant), together with payment of the prescribed fee.

With the Statement of Grounds of Appeal, filed on 9. February 1994, the Appellant (Patentee) submitted, as main request, a new, restricted set of Claims 1 to 16, and argued that the appeal was well-founded on the basis of these claims. The set of claims differed from those of the sole auxiliary request underlying the decision under appeal only in that the irradiation dosage level defined in Claims 1 and 14 respectively had been restricted to between 2·104 Gy and 3·104 Gy (2 and 3 megarads).

V. Following the postponement, because of the sudden illness of the Representative of one of the parties, until 18 September 1997, of oral proceedings previously appointed by the Board for 25 June 1997, the Board issued, on 11 July 1997, a communication in which objection, resulting from the amendments made during the proceedings and therefore arising from them, was raised against this set of claims, in particular under Article 84 EPC, that certain essential features were missing.

VI. In reply to this communication the Appellant filed, on 18. August 1997, two further sets of claims forming, respectively, Auxiliary Request I (Claims 1 to 16) and Auxiliary Request II (Claims 1 to 15).

Claim 1 of Auxiliary Request II read as follows:

"A coextruded heat shrinkable, three layer film suitable for packaging primal and sub-primal meat cuts and processed meats comprising:

a first outer layer comprising a first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9. to 15 weight percent;

a core layer comprising a barrier film formed of a polyvinylidene chloride copolymer containing at least 65. weight percent of polyvinylidene chloride, based on the weight of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer, with the remainder of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer being selected from the group consisting of vinyl chloride, acrylonitrile, and acrylate esters, and a second outer layer comprising a second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9. to 18 weight percent, based on the weight of said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, wherein said coextruded three layer film has been biaxially stretched and then irradiated to a dosage level of between 2·104 Gy and 3·104 Gy (2 and 3 megarads), as the sole irradiation treatment, so as to induce crosslinking."

Claims 2 to 12 were dependent claims directed to elaborations of the film according to Claim 1. In particular, Claim 5 read as follows:

"Film according to any of claims 1 to 3 wherein said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer is selected from the group consisting of (a) an ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0. decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 18 weight percent, based on the weight of said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, and (b) a blend of at least two ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymers, wherein one of said ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymers has a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 10 to 18 weight percent, based on the weight of said copolymer, and the other ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer has a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 2 to 10 weight percent, based on the weight of said copolymer."

Claim 13, an independent claim, read as follows:

"A process for producing a three layer film suitable for packaging primal and sub-primal meat cuts and processed meats according to any of claims 1 to 12 comprising:

(a) coextruding a first outer film layer comprising a first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 15 weight percent; a core film layer comprising a barrier film formed of a polyvinylidene chloride copolymer containing at least 65 weight percent of polyvinylidene chloride, based on the weight of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer, with the remainder of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer being selected from the group consisting of vinyl chloride, acrylonitril, and acrylate esters; and a second outer film layer comprising a second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 18 weight percent, based on the weight of said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer,

(b) biaxially stretching said film; and

(c) irradiating said film to a dosage level of between 2·104 Gy and 3·104 Gy (2 and 3 megarads), as the sole irradiation treatment, so as to induce crosslinking."

Claims 14 and 15 were dependent claims directed to elaborations of the process of Claim 13.

VII. Oral proceedings were held before the Board on 18. September 1997.

In his preliminary, provisional remarks at the outset of the proceedings, the Chairman of the Board drew the Appellant's attention to the contents of the communication previously issued by the Board, and in particular informed him that:

(a) Claims 1 and 14 of the Main Request and Auxiliary Request I were considered to be open to objection at least on the grounds set out in paragraph 1 of the communication issued by the Board, in that they did not contain any reference to the essential features of the first and second outer layers of the film, and were thus likely to be rejected.

(b) Claims 1 and 13 of Auxiliary Request II were open to objection that certain of the features presented as essential in the description of the patent as granted, in particular on page 3, lines 19 to 29, and page 3, last line to page 4, line 10, appeared only in the newly inserted Claim 5. These features should be incorporated in Claims 1 and 13.

(c) Claims 1 and 13 of Auxiliary Request II were also open to objection in that the basis of the % vinyl acetate content of the first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer was unstated.

(d) No attempt had been made to summarise the arguments of the parties in relation to the substantive issue of inventive step, because the Board was first of all concerned to have a set of claims which was clear in the sense of Article 84 EPC, upon which to base its decision.

The Representative of the Appellant then indicated that it was no longer his intention to defend the Main Request or Auxiliary Request I, but that the claims of Auxiliary Request II would be relied upon as a new Main Request, subject to a further limitation based on the features of Claim 5.

Having heard the Respondents, who submitted that two further features, namely the overall thickness of the film and the maximum allowable percentage of polyvinylidene chloride in the copolymer of the barrier layer were also essential and should be incorporated in the main claims, the Chairman adjourned the proceedings a number of times to allow the Appellant to prepare and to submit his eventual main request.

VIII. This request of the Appellant, which formed his sole, final request, was a set of Claims 1 to 13, Claim 1 of which reads as follows:

"A coextruded heat shrinkable, three layer film suitable for packaging primal and sub-primal meat cuts and processed meats comprising:

a first outer layer comprising a first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9. to 15 weight percent;

a core layer comprising a barrier film formed of a polyvinylidene chloride copolymer containing at least 65. weight percent of polyvinylidene chloride, based on the weight of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer, with the remainder of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer being selected from the group consisting of vinyl chloride, acrylonitrile, and acrylate esters; and a second outer layer comprising a second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, selected from the group consisting of (a) an ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 18 weight percent, based on the weight of said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, and (b) a blend of at least two ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymers, wherein one of said ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymers has a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 10 to 18 weight percent, based on the weight of said copolymer, and the other ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer has a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 2. to 10 weight percent, based on the weight of said copolymer.

wherein said coextruded three layer film has a total thickness of from 0.04 mm (1.75 mils) to 0.076 mm (3.0 mils). and been biaxially stretched and then irradiated to a dosage level of between 2·104 Gy and 3·104 Gy (2 and 3 megarads), as the sole irradiation treatment, so as to induce crosslinking."

Claims 2 to 10 were dependent claims directed to elaborations of the film according to Claim 1.

Claim 11, an independent claim, reads as follows:

"A process for producing a three layer film suitable for packaging primal and sub-primal meat cuts and processed meats according to any of claims 1 to 10 comprising:

(a) co-extruding a first outer film layer comprising a first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 15 weight percent; a core film layer comprising a barrier film formed of a polyvinylidene chloride copolymer containing at least 65 weight percent of polyvinylidene chloride, based on the weight of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer, with the remainder of said polyvinylidene chloride copolymer being selected from the group consisting of vinyl chloride, acrylonitril, and acrylate esters; and a second outer film layer comprising a second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having a melt index of from 0.1 to 1.0 decigram per minute and a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 18 weight percent, based on the weight of said second ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer,

(b) biaxially stretching said film; and

(c) irradiating said film to a dosage level of between 2·104 Gy and 3·104 Gy (2 and 3 megarads), as the sole irradiation treatment, so as to induce crosslinking."

Claims 12 and 13 were dependent claims directed to elaborations of the process of Claim 13.

IX. In relation to the allowability under Article 84 of this set of claims, the Appellant argued at the oral proceedings substantially as follows:

(i) The objections of the Board had been met by incorporating the subject-matter of Claim 5 into Claim 1;

(ii) The objections of the Respondents to the absence of a specific limitation of thickness of the claimed film had been met by incorporating the subject-matter of Claim 10 into Claim 1;

(iii) The objection of the Respondents that an upper limit of 90% on the percentage of polyvinylidene chloride in the copolymer of the barrier layer should be incorporated into Claim 1 was badly taken, because the skilled person reading the patent in suit would appreciate from the description what percentage of polyvinylidene chloride he should use.

X. The Respondents repeated their conviction that the absence of any upper limit in Claim 1 for the polyvinylidene chloride content of the copolymer of the barrier layer rendered the claim unclear.

After reiterating his opening remarks concerning the passages of description containing references to essential features of the film/process claimed in the patent in suit, and ascertaining that no further observations or amendments were forthcoming on the subject of compliance with Article 84 EPC, the Chairman then invited the parties to present their final requests, and closed the discussion.

XI. The Appellant requested the grant of a patent on his eventual main request submitted during oral proceedings.

The Respondents requested that the appeal be dismissed.

1. The appeal is admissible.

2. The decision is based on the following text of the patent in suit:

Claims: 1 to 13 as finally presented at the oral proceedings before the Board (Section VIII, above).

Description: Pages 2 to 11 of the patent as granted.

3. Amendments

No objection was raised by the Respondents against the amended claims under Article 123(2) or 123(3) EPC. Nor does the Board see any reason to raise such an objection of its own motion. Consequently, the amended claims are allowable under Article 123 EPC.

4. Clarity

The issue of clarity depends on the essential features of the composition of the three individual layers in the film claimed in Claim 1 and produced according to the process of Claim 11.

4.1. As regards the composition of the first outer layer, the description of the patent in suit states, in a sentence beginning on page 3 at line 16, "In accordance with this invention the heat shrinkable multilayer film having a first outer layer comprising a first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, said first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer having ... a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 15 percent, based on the weight of said first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer;...".

In independent Claims 1 and 11, however, the phrase "based on the weight of said first ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer" is missing.

4.1.1. This deficiency was referred to in the introductory remarks of the Chairman at the oral proceedings.

4.1.2. Consequently, the basis of the percentage by weight of vinyl acetate in the ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer in Claims 1 and 11 is not clearly defined, and the claim does not meet the requirements of Article 84 EPC.

4.2. In connection with the composition of the "second outer layer", in Claim 1, the description, corresponding to Claim 1, of the two alternatives (a) and (b) is in a sentence (page 3, lines 16 to 27) which is immediately followed by a statement, which reads: "The blend (b) of said at least two ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymers has a vinyl acetate content of from 9 to 18 weight percent, ... based on the weight of said copolymers." (page 3, lines 27 to 29). This statement is furthermore repeated in a subsequent passage (page 4, lines 8 to 10).

4.2.1. Thus, according to the relevant description, the case (b) is subject to the limitation applying to case (a), namely that the overall content of vinyl acetate is from 9 to 18, and preferably 10 to 15 weight percent, based on the weight of these copolymers. This limitation, although present in Claim 1 of Auxiliary Request II prior to the incorporation of the subject-matter of Claim 5, is missing from the final form of Claim 1. This is because, in incorporating the subject-matter of Claim 5 in Claim 1, the relevant overall limitation was deleted.

4.2.2. This deficiency was adverted to in the final remarks of the Chairman, who referred specifically to the relevant passages on page 3 at lines 16 to 31 and page 3, last line to page 4, line 10.

4.2.3. Thus, with Claim 1 in its final form in the sole request, the skilled person reading the patent specification as a whole would understand, from the description, that an overall limitation of 9 to 18 weight percent of vinyl acetate is essential in the copolymer of the second outer layer. On reading Claim 1, however, he would find that this limitation is not required.

4.2.4. Thus there is considerable confusion as to the essential features of the composition of this layer, so that the claim, when read in the light of the description, is not clear (Article 84 EPC).

4.3. Whilst the "barrier layer" is defined in Claims 1 and 11. as containing "at least 65 weight percent of polyvinylidene chloride", the description states that, "If the vinylidene chloride content is more than 90 weight percent, the polyvinylidene chloride copolymer is generally not extrudable." (page 3, lines 45 to 53, in particular lines 52 to 53). The film is, however, defined in Claim 1 as being "coextruded", and independent Claim 11 requires the step of coextruding.

4.3.1. This objection was raised by Respondent 02 during the oral proceedings.

4.3.2. In the Board's view, there is a conflict, in the light of this description, between the coextruded character required of the claimed films on the one hand, and the absence of the relevant limitation without which such character is, according to the description, generally unfeasible, on the other.

4.3.3. The argument of the Appellant, that the skilled person reading the description would understand from the relevant passage which percentages of polyvinylidene chloride in the barrier film should be used is not convincing, since the relevant passage does not resolve the above conflict, but on the contrary establishes it.

4.3.4. Consequently, the requirements of Article 84 EPC are not met in relation to the definition of the barrier layer in Claim 1.

4.4. Even if these unclarities had not been present, the fact that the amendments undertaken in respect of Claim 1 during the oral proceedings were not effected correspondingly in Claim 11 would itself have resulted in confusion as to the essential features between Claims 1 and 11, and thus have led to unclarity as to the essential features in the sense of Article 84 EPC.

4.5. In summary, the claims of the eventual main and sole request of the Appellant still fail to meet the requirements of Article 84 EPC.

5. It must be emphasised in this connection that, whilst amended claims may be admitted at a late stage in the procedure shortly before or during oral proceedings if they are clearly allowable, if there is good reason for the late submission or if they deal with objections from the Board of Appeal or the Opponent ("Case Law of the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office", European Patent Office, 1996, page 349, Section 12.3.1), none of these conditions apply in the present case.

5.1. On the contrary, the claims forming the request of the Appellant, which were presented at a late stage of the oral proceedings were, for the reasons given, quite clearly unallowable.

5.2. Furthermore, the Appellant had repeatedly been warned, both in writing by a communication of the Board prior to the oral proceedings, and verbally at the oral proceedings itself, that there were features in the description, the absence of which from the main claims would result in deficiencies rendering those claims objectionable under Article 84 EPC.

5.3. The freedom of the Board to offer specific advice to one of the parties as to how an objection might be overcome, even when such an objection stems from the Board itself, is in this connection severely limited, especially where, as here, in inter partes proceedings, the preservation of judicial impartiality before all the parties is a paramount requirement.

5.4. Whilst the Board would have been justified, under the circumstances, in refusing altogether to consider the set of claims finally presented as the main request at the oral proceedings, nevertheless it chose, in its discretion, to admit the amended claims and to consider them in the light of the issue already raised and on which the parties had had opportunity to present their observations, namely that of compliance with Article 84 EPC.

5.5. Since, however, there had already been a number of adjournments of the proceedings, the Board saw no alternative but to decide the matter finally.

Order

ORDER

For these reasons it is decided that:

1. The main request fails to meet the requirements of Article 84 EPC.

2. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.

Footer - Service & support
  • Service & support
    • Website updates
    • Availability of online services
    • FAQ
    • Publications
    • Procedural communications
    • Contact us
    • Subscription centre
    • Official holidays
    • Glossary
Footer - More links
  • Jobs & careers
  • Press centre
  • Single Access Portal
  • Procurement
  • Boards of Appeal
Facebook
European Patent Office
EPO Jobs
Instagram
EuropeanPatentOffice
Linkedin
European Patent Office
EPO Jobs
EPO Procurement
X (formerly Twitter)
EPOorg
EPOjobs
Youtube
TheEPO
Footer
  • Legal notice
  • Terms of use
  • Data protection and privacy
  • Accessibility